ARTDESENT — Art, Design, Entertainment

Reimagining Iconic Structures: New Monuments, New Narratives

As cities confront the legacies of their public monuments, proposals like the Sierra Leone Carrier Corps memorial and a triumphal arch by Donald Trump reveal divergent approaches to collective memory.

By Clara Hoffmann··3 min read
photo of gray concrete building
Glossy steel facade · Ashim D’Silva (Unsplash License)

In Freetown, Sierra Leone, a memorial proposal for the Carrier Corps—those conscripted to support British troops during both World Wars—has sparked significant discussions about public monuments. Commissioned by the Sierra Leone Ministry of Tourism and Cultural Affairs in 2022, the project seeks to recover a long-overlooked history. The design brief calls for a balance between commemoration and acknowledgment of the exploitation behind the Carrier Corps' service. Munda+'s winning design features an elliptical structure encircling a preserved banyan tree, symbolizing resilience. Jury member David Adjaye praised its "capacity to foster reflection without monumentalizing subjugation."

Conversely, the recently canceled plans for a triumphal arch proposed by the Trump administration in 2019 aimed to celebrate the 'spirit of America.' Architect John C. Zadrozny's design drew criticism for its reliance on imperial motifs from classical antiquity, overlooking America's complex historical narratives. The project was shelved in early 2023 after budget overruns and public backlash, highlighting a trend of using monumental architecture to assert power rather than interrogate it.

These two projects illustrate how cities navigate their historical identities. Following the removal of Confederate statues in the U.S. and colonial-era figures in Europe, debates about which figures deserve permanence have surged. Unlike contested works in museum storerooms, monuments are part of daily life, shaping the urban experience.

Historian Karen Till noted in The Journal of Monument Studies that “monuments are never neutral; even in stillness, they act.” This emphasizes the stakes involved in redesigning or replacing them. The Sierra Leone competition offers a valuable perspective. Its brief avoided heroism, instead asking for designs that "speak to collective experiences and encourage multiple perspectives." Munda+ created a site for gatherings, performances, and vigils, prioritizing dialogue over grandeur. This approach mirrors the Memorial to Enslaved Laborers at the University of Virginia, completed in 2020, which also emphasized interaction.

The Trump arch, however, leaned heavily on grandeur. Its proposed site on the National Mall in Washington D.C.—already saturated with monuments—would have placed it alongside the Lincoln Memorial and the Washington Monument. While those spaces invite diverse interpretations of American ideals, the arch faced criticism for its uncritical glorification of a narrow narrative. Architectural historian Barry Bergdoll described it as “a monument not to history but to hubris.”

If the Carrier Corps memorial and the Trump arch represent opposing ends of a spectrum, what lies in between? In Germany, the ongoing Stumbling Stones project, initiated by artist Gunter Demnig in 1992, offers a decentralized model for remembering the Holocaust. Each Stolperstein, or brass-plated stone, marks the last known address of a victim of Nazi persecution. As of 2023, over 100,000 stones exist across Europe, inviting interaction without imposing it. Their accumulation creates a presence that insists on the personal within the public.

The processes behind these projects matter as much as their outcomes. Collaborative design processes, like those used by Munda+ or in the creation of the Memorial to Enslaved Laborers, contrast sharply with unilateral commissions like the Trump arch. They emphasize the importance of involving affected communities as co-authors of public memory.

Yet, such processes face challenges. In Berlin, the Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe, completed in 2005, faced criticism for lacking consultation with Jewish organizations during its inception. Although regarded today as a landmark of Holocaust commemoration, its history reminds us that even well-intentioned projects can falter when stakeholder voices are excluded.

Looking forward, reimagining public monuments will require greater conceptual flexibility. Technologies like augmented reality (AR) offer possibilities for creating adaptive, non-permanent memorials that can evolve with changing societal values. In 2021, the Design Museum in London explored this potential with the exhibition Virtual Monuments: History in Motion, showcasing AR interventions that re-contextualized traditional statues. These experiments suggest ways of balancing permanence with adaptability.

The debate over public monuments is not merely academic; it shapes the landscapes where communities articulate their identities. The Sierra Leone Carrier Corps memorial, as it moves toward construction, suggests architecture can transcend the binary of celebration and condemnation. Whether other cities will follow its lead—or retreat into the comforts of marble grandeur—remains an open question.

#public monuments#historical memory#urban identity#monument redesign#community dialogue
Sources
Clara Hoffmann — Clara Hoffmann covers architecture and contested urbanism from Berlin. Former editor at Bauwelt; trained at the TU Berlin.
Continue reading