ARTDESENT — Art, Design, Entertainment

Rethinking Civic Futures at the Sharjah Architecture Triennial

The second edition of the Sharjah Architecture Triennial challenges architects to address pressing social, economic, and environmental urgencies through infrastructure that serves communities.

By Clara Hoffmann··3 min read
a black wall with a neon sign that says our reality is your future
· Daniel Silva (Unsplash License)

The Sharjah Architecture Triennial opens on 11 November 2023 in Sharjah’s dense urban landscape. It asks: how can architecture foster resilience and equity in rapidly changing cities? Curated by Tosin Oshinowo, the theme The Beauty of Impermanence emphasizes adaptability in civic infrastructure that meets community needs.

Oshinowo, known for her human-centered design, connects this theme to vernacular practices in Africa, the Middle East, and South Asia—regions where resource constraints have led to innovative architecture. In her curatorial statement, she states: "Impermanence is not fragility; it is a framework for continuous growth. Our challenge is to translate this into structures that extend beyond the physical to the social and environmental." The Triennial’s headquarters, adapted from a 1970s Brutalist school, exemplifies this ethos by repurposing existing buildings for new civic functions.

The program includes installations, workshops, and discussions, with a highlight being speculative architectural proposals for communal spaces. A project by Lebanese design studio MTA reimagines Beirut’s municipal spaces as modular and temporary, adaptable to urban pressures. Pakistani architect Yasmeen Lari proposes zero-carbon bamboo shelters, which she describes as "architecture for the 99%." Her work showcases the potential of low-cost materials and participatory methods for broader social inclusion.

This focus on civic infrastructure marks a shift from signature aesthetics to systemic impact. The Triennial critiques "iconic architecture," which curator Hanan Sayed Worrell argues often prioritizes spectacle over sustainability. In Sharjah, a city transformed by rapid urbanization, this critique is particularly relevant. The emirate’s development often neglects human-scale needs like public green spaces and walkable streets.

However, the Triennial must confront contradictions within its context. Sharjah’s development model relies on top-down planning, raising questions about grassroots participation in showcased proposals. The tension between a temporary exhibition and long-term strategies looms large. Can this event transcend performative aspects to drive real change?

Ole Bouman, founding director of the Design Society in Shenzhen, will address these dilemmas at the opening symposium. He will discuss the "politics of impermanence" in urban megaprojects, advocating for a shift from static endpoints to iterative processes. This aligns with the Triennial’s focus on adaptable strategies, suggesting a roadmap for balancing ambition with local needs.

Institutions like the Sharjah Art Foundation and the Africa Institute foster this dialogue, merging art, architecture, and social practice. Hoor Al Qasimi, president of the Sharjah Art Foundation, emphasizes this ethos: "Our aim has always been to integrate cultural production into the life of the city rather than isolating it in elite enclaves." The Triennial builds on this legacy.

The global relevance of the Triennial lies in its challenge to dominant design paradigms. By highlighting models from the Global South, it seeks to recalibrate architectural thinking. Whether this shift succeeds or gets co-opted by Western frameworks remains uncertain. Mariam Kamara, founder of Atelier Masōmī, asserts: "The power dynamics of who can define architectural value need to be continually dismantled. Otherwise, even well-intentioned initiatives risk reproducing inequities."

Sharjah’s urban challenges provide a testing ground for these ideas. Al Jubail Market, a community hub renovated in 2020, embodies adaptive reuse and reflects the city’s evolving priorities. It features prominently in the Triennial's walking tours, showcasing porous architecture that integrates public and commercial functions.

The Sharjah Architecture Triennial raises more questions than it answers, which may be its strength. By framing impermanence as an opportunity, it encourages architects, policymakers, and citizens to rethink their relationship with the built environment. The impact of its proposals remains to be seen. As Oshinowo puts it: "The success of this Triennial will not be measured in how many buildings adopt its principles, but in whether it reshapes the conversations that lead to them."

#architecture#sharjah#community#design#infrastructure#triennial
Clara Hoffmann — Clara Hoffmann covers architecture and contested urbanism from Berlin. Former editor at Bauwelt; trained at the TU Berlin.
Continue reading